A pan of Church Supper Noodles Romanoff comes out of the oven with a golden, lightly crisp top and bubbling edges, and the kitchen smells of toasted Parmesan and garlic. Under the crust, the egg noodles are tender but not soft, coated in a tangy, creamy sauce with small soft curds of cottage cheese. It’s an easy bake with about 15 minutes of work and 30 in the oven, and it makes 6 servings, so dinner is on the table in under an hour.
Serve it hot as a main with a green vegetable, or as a side next to roast chicken or steak. It’s also a good dish to bring to a potluck, since it can be assembled ahead and baked when you need it. Stirring the sauce takes a couple of minutes, and the one decision that really matters is how far you cook the noodles before they go into the oven.
From Boiling Pot to Bubbling Top
Start with a large pot of well-salted water at a full rolling boil, because egg noodles release starch and stick together in too little water. Pull them while a bite still has a firm, slightly chalky center, usually a minute or two before the package time, and drain them well. They’ll look a little underdone, and that’s right, since they finish cooking in the oven.
The cheese mixture comes together in a minute. It should be thick and spoonable, like loose sour cream, with white curds of cottage cheese scattered through it, and it smells of garlic and butter. Taste it now. The noodles carry no salt of their own, so this is your only chance to season the dish, and it should taste a little saltier than you’d want to eat on its own.
Layer half the noodles, half the sauce, then repeat. Around the 15-minute mark the edges start to bubble and the room smells of toasted cheese. By 25 to 30 minutes the top is golden with a few darker spots. If it’s still pale at 30 minutes, give it 5 more. If it looks loose, don’t worry, because the sauce tightens as the dish stands for a few minutes.

Noodles Cooked Short of Done
Noodles in a casserole keep cooking twice, first in the pot and then in the oven, where they soak up moisture from the sauce. A noodle boiled to full softness has no room left to absorb anything and turns mushy and pasty by the time the top browns. One pulled at al dente still has a firm center, so it swells in the oven and finishes tender.
The sauce is built on the same logic. Sour cream gives acidity and fat, the butter adds richness, and cottage cheese supplies soft curds that hold some of their shape and release whey into the noodles as they heat. Parmesan seasons the mix and browns on top, where the surface dries first. Layering half and half makes sure every layer meets sauce, rather than leaving one dry stack of noodles beneath a wet one.
Salt works in two places. The cooking water seasons the noodles from the inside, and the sauce seasons what sits around them. Cottage cheese and Parmesan are both salty, but a pound of plain noodles dilutes them, so a generous hand with salt and pepper at the sauce stage is what keeps the finished pan from tasting flat.
Dry Tops and Watery Bottoms
- The noodles are mushy. They were boiled to full package time or beyond. Next time drain them a minute or two early, while the center is still firm.
- The dish is dry and stiff. It baked too long or the noodles went in without enough sauce. Pull it as soon as the top is golden, and spread the sauce all the way to the corners of each layer.
- There’s liquid pooling at the bottom. The noodles weren’t drained well, or the cottage cheese was especially wet. Drain the noodles thoroughly and let the dish stand 5 minutes after baking so the sauce can tighten.
- The taste is flat. The sauce wasn’t seasoned enough for a full pound of unsalted noodles. Add salt and pepper and taste before layering, and use well-salted water.
- The top stays pale. Your oven may run cool or the dish may be deeper than 9 x 13 inches. Bake 5 minutes longer, and don’t use the broiler unless you can stand over it.
- Butter or oil pools on top. The butter wasn’t stirred in well. Whisk the melted butter into the sauce until no slick remains.
Chicken, Mushrooms and Herbs
These changes keep the method the same and only adjust the sauce. They aren’t part of the recipe card, so treat them as starting points.
- Chicken. Fold about 2 cups (280 g) of cooked, diced chicken into the cheese mixture. The dish needs to reach 165°F (74°C) in the center, so check the middle with a thermometer. For a different noodle dinner built around chicken, the site’s creamy chicken and noodles in the Crockpot is made in a slow cooker.
- Mushrooms. Brown 8 ounces (225 g) of sliced mushrooms in a skillet for 6 to 8 minutes until their liquid has cooked off, cool them, then stir them into the sauce. Raw mushrooms release water in the oven and make the dish loose.
- Fresh herbs. Stir 2 tablespoons of chopped parsley or chives into the sauce, or scatter them over the top after baking so they stay bright green.
- Extra Parmesan. Sprinkle 2 tablespoons over the top before baking for a thicker golden crust.
Chicken and mushrooms dilute the seasoning, so taste the sauce again and add salt if it needs it. Keep the total amount of sauce close to the original, so the layers still heat through in the same 25 to 30 minutes.

Dairy and Noodle Substitutes
Full-fat sour cream and cottage cheese give the richest result. Small-curd cottage cheese blends more smoothly into the sauce than large curds. Grated Parmesan from a wedge melts better than the dry shaker kind, which often contains anti-caking ingredients and doesn’t brown as well.
| Ingredient | Swap | What changes |
|---|---|---|
| Sour cream | Plain Greek yogurt, 1 cup | Tangier and thicker, bake the same time |
| Cottage cheese | Ricotta, 1 cup | Smoother and creamier, milder in flavor |
| Egg noodles | Gluten-free noodles | Cook a minute short, they absorb more sauce |
| Egg noodles | Whole wheat noodles | Nuttier and firmer, cook al dente |
| Full-fat dairy | Low-fat versions | Less rich, and the dish releases more liquid |
Wide or medium egg noodles both work. Wide ones hold more sauce in each bite, while medium ones pack the layers more evenly. Very thin noodles soften too fast in the oven. The dish contains wheat, egg and milk, so it can’t be made dairy-free or egg-free with a simple swap. Check the label on gluten-free noodles and on the Parmesan, since packaged cheese sometimes carries added starch.
Making It Ahead and Storing It
You can assemble the dish, cover it and refrigerate it for up to a day before baking. Take it out of the refrigerator while the oven heats, and expect a few extra minutes in the oven. Judge doneness by the golden top and the bubbling edges, not by the clock.
The assembled, unbaked dish also freezes. Wrap it tightly, freeze it for up to 2 months, and thaw it overnight in the refrigerator before baking. The sauce is a little softer after freezing, but it still bakes up creamy.
Refrigerate leftovers within 2 hours of baking. Packed in an airtight container, they keep for up to 3 days, which sits inside the 3 to 4 day window in federal food safety guidance for cooked leftovers.
Reheat portions covered with foil in a 350°F (175°C) oven for about 20 minutes, or in the microwave, until they reach 165°F (74°C) in the center. Portion leftovers into shallow containers so they cool quickly. Stir in a spoonful of milk or sour cream if the noodles have dried out in the refrigerator.
Sides for a Creamy Casserole
A casserole this rich wants something green and plain beside it. Steamed green beans or broccoli with a squeeze of lemon cut through the cream, and so does a simple salad with a sharp dressing. Crusty bread or garlic knots are good for mopping up the sauce at the edges of the dish.
If you’re serving it as a side, it suits a meaty main. The site’s baked hamburger steak with creamy mushroom gravy is a natural partner, though with two creamy dishes on one plate you’ll want a plain vegetable alongside for contrast. Roast chicken or sliced ham works the same way, since the noodles stand in for potatoes or rice.
To drink, lemonade or iced tea suits a hearty plate, and a crisp white wine works for a dinner with guests. Serve the noodles hot, a few minutes after they leave the oven, when the sauce is soft and the top still has some crunch.

FAQ
Is this the same as the boxed or frozen noodles Romanoff?
Not exactly. Boxed and frozen versions use their own seasoning mixes or sauces, and what's sold changes by store and over time. This from-scratch pan is close in spirit, a creamy baked noodle dish, but it's built on sour cream, cottage cheese and Parmesan, which are easy to find in any grocery store.
Is it a main dish or a side dish?
Either. It's filling enough to be a main with a green vegetable, and it serves well as a side next to roast chicken, steak or ham. Six servings as a main is a generous portion, so if it's a side for a larger meal, the pan will stretch further.
Should I cover the dish while it bakes?
No, bake it uncovered so the top turns golden and the edges bubble. If the top is browning faster than the center is heating, lay a loose sheet of foil over the dish for the last few minutes. Covering from the start steams the top and leaves it pale and wet.
Can I use a smaller or different dish?
A 3-quart casserole holds the same amount and works as written. For half the recipe, use an 8-inch square dish and start checking around 25 minutes. A deeper dish packs the noodles thicker, so it needs more time, and you should judge by a golden top and bubbling edges.
Can I smooth out the cottage cheese?
Yes, if you don't like the curds. Blend the cottage cheese for 20 to 30 seconds before stirring it into the sauce, or use small-curd cottage cheese, which disappears more easily. Blending gives a smoother, more uniform sauce, but the classic version keeps some soft curds in the noodles.
Can I double the recipe?
Yes. Use two 9 x 13-inch dishes rather than one deep dish, since a thick layer takes longer to heat through and the top browns first. Put both on one rack, or swap them halfway through if your oven has hot spots, and look for a golden top and bubbling edges in each dish.

Baked Church Supper Noodles Romanoff
- Prep 15 min
- Cook 30 min
- Total 45 min
Cook mode: your screen stays on and the current step is shown larger.
Ingredients
Steps
- Step 1 of 6
Cook the egg noodles in a large pot of boiling salted water according to the package directions until al dente, with a firm center, then drain well and set aside.
- Step 2 of 6
Stir the sour cream, cottage cheese, Parmesan, melted butter, garlic powder, salt and pepper together in a mixing bowl until well blended, with no streaks of sour cream left, then taste and season generously.
- Step 3 of 6
Heat the oven to 350°F (175°C).
- Step 4 of 6
Spread half of the noodles in a 9 x 13-inch (23 x 33 cm) baking dish, spoon half of the cheese mixture over them, then repeat with the remaining noodles and cheese mixture.
- Step 5 of 6
Bake for 25 to 30 minutes, until the top is golden and the edges are bubbling.
- Step 6 of 6
Let the dish stand for about 5 minutes so the sauce settles, then serve warm.
Nutrition
- Calories
- 505 kcal
- Protein
- 19 g
- Fat
- 22 g
- Carbohydrates
- 57 g
- Sugar
- 5 g
- Fiber
- 3 g
- Salt
- 1.2 g
Approximate values per serving.
How did it turn out?
Related searches
- Church Supper Noodles Romanoff
- noodles romanoff
- noodles romanoff recipe
- romanoff noodles recipe
- recipe noodles romanoff
- betty crocker noodles romanoff
- recipe for noodles romanoff
- romanoff noodles
- noodle romanoff recipe
- noodles romanoff betty crocker
- what happened to stouffer's noodles romanoff
- betty crocker noodles romanoff recipe
- noodles romanoff recipes
- stouffer's noodles romanoff
- noodles romanoff betty crocker recipe
- noodles romanoff box mix
- noodles romanoff in a box
- noodles romanoff recipe betty crocker
- boxed noodles romanoff
- For metrics
- refresh
- noodles romanoff box
- where can i buy noodles romanoff
- noodles romanoff recipe easy
- noodles romanoff with cottage cheese
- stouffers noodles romanoff
- why did stouffer's discontinue noodles romanoff
- authentic noodles romanoff recipe
- baked noodles romanoff
- best noodles romanoff recipe
- betty crocker noodles romanoff copycat recipe
- betty crocker noodles romanoff in a box
- copycat noodles romanoff
- creamy noodles romanoff
- creamy noodles romanoff recipe
